Connect With Us on Twitter
Follow@nytimesworldfor international breaking news and headlines.
Two Swedish journalists arrested in the company of rebels in Ethiopia's restive Ogaden region have been found guilty of supporting terrorism. The case is attracting wide attention from international human rights and press freedom groups.
Reporter Martin Schibbye and photographer Johan Persson appeared stunned as Ethiopian High Court judge Shemsu Sirgaga pronounced them guilty of aiding a terrorist group and entering the country illegally.
They face a maximum of 18 years in prison. Sentencing is set for next week.
The two Swedes were arrested June 30 in Ethiopia's Somali region while traveling with rebels of the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF), which is fighting for regional autonomy. The region has been off-limits to most outsiders for years while government troops carry out what human rights groups allege is a harsh counterinsurgency campaign against the ONLF.
Schibbye and Persson admitted entering Ethiopia illegally from Somalia, but denied supporting the rebels. They told the court they were investigating a Swedish firm allegedly involved in oil exploration in the conflict zone.
The case is being closely followed in Sweden because of the firm's ties to Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt.
In reading the verdict, Judge Shemsu told the pair he accepted their claim to be journalists, but said it was hard to believe they could be impartial while breaking the laws of a sovereign country.
The verdict surprised the large contingent of foreign observers, diplomats and Swedish journalists who had been following the trial. Ingrid Dahlback of the Swedish news agency TT said the weight of evidence had raised hopes that the defendants would be found not guilty of supporting terrorism.
“I thought the judge would at least take some of the arguments from the defense, but as it seems he went almost only on the prosecutor's line," said Dahlback. "So it's very bad news for the Swedish journalists, and I would say it's bad news for freedom of the press.”
An ashen-faced Swedish ambassador to Ethiopia, Jens Odlander, said the next move would be up to authorities in Stockholm.
“This is very disappointing,' said Odlander. "We have to analyze the situation.”
The reaction from Stockholm was swift. Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt issued a statement saying the journalists were on a legitimate assignment and should be freed immediately. He said his government was already in high-level contact with Ethiopian officials on the matter.
Mats Larsson, who covered the trial for Sweden's mass-circulation Dagens Nyheter newspaper, says the verdict would likely have domestic political repercussions.
“There's been a big discussion in Sweden about the role of the Swedish foreign minister," said Larsson. "There are accusations that he has seen these two guys as left-wingers in the wrong part of the world and that this was their own fault that they came into this situation. And the result of this trial is a disaster for the Swedish government and for the relatives and for the two Swedish journalists and for freedom of speech in the world.”
The verdict also sparked condemnation from human rights and press freedom defenders. Amnesty International called the two journalists “prisoners of conscience," and said it sees no evidence they were supporting the ONLF.
The media advocacy group Reporters Without Borders earlier sent a letter to the United Nations accusing Ethiopia of muzzling dissent.
Eight Ethiopian journalists are also currently on trial on terrorism-related charges - three in person and five others in absentia. Some of them could face the death penalty if convicted.
Closing arguments in the case were scheduled for December 21 as Wednesday's court session ended in Addis Ababa on Wednesday. Reporter Martin Schibbye and photographer Johan Persson were arrested in Ethiopia's Ogaden region where Ethiopian forces have clashed with the Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) on July 1. The area is off limits to foreigners and the duo entered Ethiopia from Somalia without visas, travelling with rebel soldiers. They were arrested after a gun battle erupted between Ethiopian troops and ONLF fighters, and are charged with supporting a terrorist group and entering the country illegally. The journalists were slightly injured in the fighting and several rebels were killed. Schibbye and Persson face up to 15 years in jail if found guilty. A British and an American war correspondent called as expert witnesses by the defence appeared in court on Wednesday, telling the court that entering a country illegally for reporting purposes is a work method commonly used by journalists in conflict zones. Appearing in court on Tuesday, Schibbye and Persson admitted contact with the outlawed ONLF but rejected accusations that they received weapons training. In a court session last month, the prosecutor presented video footage said to be obtained from the journalists' own equipments showing the pair posing with automatic rifles. The prosecutor later had to admit that Ethiopian authorities had doctored some of the footage, adding audio of gunshots. The journalists said the weapons belonged to a security guard at a hotel in Somalia and not the ONLF. They said they had been posing with the weapons as they sought to interview the guard, who had been active in the Somali anti-government group al-Shabab. Investigating oil company Last month, charges of participating in terrorism were dropped due to a lack of evidence. "This video doesn't show some bizarre training with weapons in a parking lot, it shows another day at the office for a foreign correspondent," one of the accused, Martin Schibbye, told the judge.
The Ethiopian military has been accused of committing rights violations - including killings, rape and driving away local communities - in order to protect the foreign oil operations. "It was a report on [Lundin's] action in the Ogaden. Good and bad, whatever it was, was to find the facts and reporting them," Goransson said. Goransson added that he was aware the journalists planned to enter Ethiopia illegally. "They informed me and I took it as fact that the government of Ethiopia would not let them into the Ogaden," he said, adding that journalists often have to break laws to report in conflict zones. Schibbye and Persson said they met ONLF chiefs in the UK and Kenya before meeting about 20 members of the group in Ethiopia, about 40km from the Somali border. Persson said meeting with the ONLF contacts was for professional reasons only. "I came to Ethiopia for one purpose, that's to do my job as a journalist," he said. Journalists harassed Swedish diplomats have been monitoring the case closely and the Swedish embassy in Addis Ababa has among other things assisted in providing legal assistance to the defendants. "We see them as journalists who entered the country on a journalistic assignment," Teo Zetterman, a Swedish foreign ministry spokesman, told Al Jazeera. CPJ and other international journalism groups have urged Ethiopian authorities to release the pair. According to CPJ, 79 Ethiopian journalists have fled the country over the last decade after government harassment. The government has detained or expelled journalists from foreign media outlets including the Associated Press, the New York Times and the Washington Post. US-based Human Rights Watch said in September that the Ethiopian government's anti-terrorism law contained an overly broad and vague definition of terrorist acts. "The government is exploiting the law’s overly broad language to accuse peaceful critics, journalists, and political opponents of encouraging terrorism," the group said. The ONLF has been fighting for independence of the remote southeastern Ogaden region, mainly inhabited by Somalis, since 1984, claiming they have been marginalised by Ethiopian authorities. |
By Aaron Maasho
ADDIS ABABA (Reuters) - The managing editor of one of Ethiopia's few remaining independent Amharic-language newspapers publishing critical analysis of local politics said he left the country last week for fear of arrest, a U.S.-based press freedom group said.
Dawit Kebede, managing editor of Awramba Times, spent two years behind bars until 2007 over treason charges, alongside dozens of opposition officials who were rounded up following disputed polls in 2005.
He said he had been warned he would be arrested and that his paper was unlikely to continue publishing, according to the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), citing what it said Kebede had told the group.
"The Ethiopian government's persecution of those seeking to report the news and raise critical questions about issues of public interest has driven the largest number of journalists in the world into exile," Mohamed Keita, Africa Advocacy Coordinator for the CPJ said in a statement.
A 2009 anti-terrorism law introduced after a series of blasts says anyone caught publishing information that could induce readers into acts of terrorism could be jailed for between 10 to 20 years.
More than 10 journalists have been charged under the law in the past few months, according to CPJ, which says Ethiopia is close to taking the mantle of worst jailer in the continent from Eritrea, a secretive neighbouring country.
The Ethiopian government says the incarceration of journalists has nothing to do with their reporting or political affiliation.
JOURNALISTS WORRIED
But journalists are worried.
"Ever since the anti-terror law came to effect, I have become too careful to write on issues that might upset the government," a correspondent based in the capital Addis Ababa who declined to be named told Reuters.
"In effect, it has made me avoid writing on certain issues."
The government has banned five groups as terrorist organisations: the secessionist Ogaden National Liberation Front (ONLF) and Oromo Liberation Front (OLF), the exiled Ginbot 7 group, al Qaeda and Somalia's al Shabaab militants.
"It is fair that we have a law like any other country, but it is our job to write on any group and no journalist should be suspected of criminal acts by reporting on them," a local radio reporter who declined to be named said.
"It always sticks in your mind whether your publication or broadcasting of rebel statements might get you in trouble. I have come to believe that I have compromised my profession."
Terror charges have not been limited to journalists -- more than 150 opposition politicians and supporters have been detained this year, according to watchdogs.
Some analysts say Ethiopian Prime Minister Meles Zenawi's ruling party, which was re-elected with a huge parliamentary majority in 2010, is cracking down on opponents.
"The Ethiopian government is exploiting its vaguely worded anti-terror law to crush peaceful dissent," said Rona Peligal, deputy Africa director at Human Rights Watch.
Government officials insist Ethiopia's laws do not stray from international standards.
"Our law is no different to that of other developed countries. I think many of the comments are politically motivated, they are not realistic," Justice Minister Berhan Hailu told Reuters.
Berhan said the law proved Ethiopia's commitment to fighting terrorism and that all suspects were getting fair trials.
Some journalists are not convinced, and want clearer guidelines on offences that could land them in trouble.
"The law needs to clarify offences. Who would want to spend a year or two in detention before being found innocent?" a radio correspondent based in the capital said.
© Thomson Reuters 2011 All rights reserved